Key points
- On 21 November 2026 Fadli Zon said he does not deny the May 1998 rapes but objects to the word 'mass', saying he found no historical facts to support it.
- The state's TGPF verified 85 cases of sexual violence, including 52 rapes, in Jakarta, Medan and Surabaya.
- UN Special Rapporteur Radhika Coomaraswamy wrote in January 1999: 'There was mass rape but the numbers are hard to determine.'
- Komnas HAM found preliminary evidence of crimes against humanity, which by law require a widespread or systematic attack; the case has still not reached a human rights court.
- Verdict: misleading.
The claim: In a statement posted on his personal social media account on Saturday 21 November 2026, Culture Minister Fadli Zon said: "I do not deny that it (rape) happened and I strongly condemn it. If there are facts related to law or documentation, I think there is no problem," ANTARA reported. He said he objects to calling the May 1998 sexual violence "mass" rape because he sees the word as implying structured and systematic acts, and Kompas.com reported that he disagrees with the term because he has not found historical facts that support it.
He was answering Siera Tamihardja, producer of the film "Para Perasuk", who used her acceptance speech for Best Feature Film at the Indonesian Film Festival on Friday 20 November to call denial of the 1998 mass rapes "disgusting and devoid of empathy". Her criticism referred to Fadli's remarks in June 2025, when he questioned the evidence for mass rape and called it "a story", a claim NewsWLD rated false.
Our verdict: Misleading. Fadli now accepts that rapes took place, which is a shift from June 2025. But the legal and documentary record he says is needed already exists, and it was produced by the state itself. A fact-finding team set up by five senior officials verified 52 rapes among 85 cases of sexual violence in three cities. A United Nations special rapporteur who interviewed victims wrote in 1999 that "there was mass rape". The national human rights commission found preliminary evidence of crimes against humanity in the May riots, a legal category that by definition requires a widespread or systematic attack. Presenting the word "mass" as unsupported leaves out that record.
What the record shows
1. A state fact-finding team verified 52 rapes. The Joint Fact-Finding Team (TGPF) on the May 1998 riots recorded 85 verified cases of sexual violence in Jakarta and its surroundings, Medan and Surabaya: 52 rapes, 14 rapes with assault, 10 sexual assaults and 9 cases of sexual harassment, according to the National Commission on Violence Against Women (Komnas Perempuan), as cited by ANTARA and Kompas.com.
2. The team was a government body, and its findings led to a presidential decree. TGPF was created on 23 July 1998 by a joint decision of the defence minister and armed forces commander, the justice minister, the home affairs minister, the minister for women's affairs and the attorney general. Its findings were handed to President BJ Habibie and became the basis for the state's recognition of sexual violence in May 1998, followed by Presidential Decree No. 181 of 1998 creating Komnas Perempuan, the commission said in June 2025.
3. A UN special rapporteur used the words "mass rape". Radhika Coomaraswamy, the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women, visited Indonesia from late November to early December 1998. Her report (E/CN.4/1999/68/Add.3, 21 January 1999) states: "There was mass rape but the numbers are hard to determine since the Chinese community appears to be terrorized by the events and victims are reluctant to come forward." She also described a "denial culture" in which officials argued that because cases were not reported, rape must not have taken place, and wrote that she was "convinced that rape did take place" after meeting victims (text of the report, ETAN archive).
4. Komnas HAM found preliminary evidence of crimes against humanity. Acting on a TGPF recommendation, the National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM) ran a pro-justitia inquiry into the May 1998 riots and concluded there was sufficient preliminary evidence of crimes against humanity under Article 9 of Law No. 26 of 2000 on Human Rights Courts (Komnas Perempuan). Article 9 defines such crimes as acts committed "as part of a widespread or systematic attack" directed at civilians, and lists rape and other sexual violence among them (Law 26/2000, Article 9). The legal test Fadli says is missing, scale or system, is the one this finding applies.
5. The state formally acknowledged the May 1998 riots as a gross human rights violation. On 11 January 2023, President Joko Widodo said he acknowledged and deeply regretted gross human rights violations in 12 events, including "the May 1998 riots", after reading the report of a government non-judicial team (State Secretariat).
The minister's side
Fadli says he condemns the sexual violence and that his view of the term "mass" is a personal opinion, not guidance for the national history his ministry is producing. "I also did not take part in writing it and I did not direct it. Those who write this history book are of course historians with a professional background in history," he said (ANTARA). The ministry is publishing an 11-volume history of Indonesia, five volumes of which have been launched (Kompas.com). Komnas Perempuan has also said that detailed victim identities cannot be made public, to protect survivors and their families from further violence, which limits what can be published case by case.
Accountability gap
More than 28 years on, no one has been tried in a human rights court for the May 1998 riots. On 9 November 2026, Coordinating Minister Yusril Ihza Mahendra said only four of 17 alleged past gross violations had gone to court, and listed the May 1998 riots among 13 that remain stalled. He described Komnas HAM inquiry files being returned by prosecutors as insufficient for investigation. The government has formed an inter-agency working group to break the deadlock (ANTARA). Komnas Perempuan has said that denying the TGPF findings "prolongs impunity".
What remains unknown
The full number of victims, which the UN rapporteur said was hard to determine because victims were intimidated into silence. How the May 1998 sexual violence is described in the ministry's published and forthcoming history volumes. Whether the new working group will move the Komnas HAM file to an investigation.
Sources
- 1.ANTARA: Fadli Zon tegaskan kecam kekerasan seksual Mei 1998 (21 Nov 2026), antaranews.com
- 2.Kompas.com: Kata Fadli Zon yang dikritik sutradara Para Perasuk soal pemerkosaan massal (21 Nov 2026), nasional.kompas.com
- 3.Komnas Perempuan: Siaran pers merespons penyangkalan peristiwa kekerasan seksual Mei 1998 (15 Jun 2025), komnasperempuan.go.id
- 4.UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women, report E/CN.4/1999/68/Add.3 (21 Jan 1999), ETAN archive, etan.org
- 5.Law No. 26 of 2000 on Human Rights Courts, Article 9, pasal.id
- 6.State Secretariat: Pernyataan pers Presiden RI tentang pelanggaran HAM berat (11 Jan 2023), setneg.go.id
- 7.ANTARA: Pemerintah bentuk pokja atasi hambatan penanganan kasus HAM berat (9 Nov 2026), antaranews.com
- 8.NewsWLD claim: Fadli Zon on May 1998 mass rape (June 2025), newswld.com




