Key points
- Five commodities were removed from the critical-minerals classification.
- The classification informs policy but does not grant mining permits.
- Environmental and community impacts require project-level evidence.
Indonesia has narrowed its official list of critical minerals from 47 to 42, a change with implications for how the state weighs mining permits, domestic processing and industrial security. Energy and Mineral Resources Minister Bahlil Lahadalia signed Ministerial Decision 434.K/MB.01/MEM.B/2026 on 10 November. The decision is in force, but it does not itself approve a mine, award a tax incentive or waive environmental safeguards.
What actually changed
The 2026 decision and its annex list 42 commodities. The earlier 2023 decision listed 47. Comparing the lists, hafnium, mercury, palladium, ruthenium and thorium no longer appear. The new list retains nickel, cobalt, lithium, copper, tin, bauxite-derived aluminium, graphite and rare-earth elements, among others. Scandium is listed separately rather than counted within the rare-earth entry.
This is not a ban on mining the five removed materials. Nor does continued inclusion mean a project automatically qualifies for preferential treatment. The legal text says the classification may be considered by competent ministries, agencies and provincial governments when developing policies. The distinction matters: a policy reference is not an operating licence.
Why the criteria matter
The decision defines critical minerals through their importance to the economy and strategic industries, including defence, and their exposure to supply disruption with limited substitutes. Its criteria cover domestic industrial demand and added value, global supply vulnerability and import dependence, and the resilience of reserves needed to supply processing and refining facilities.
That last emphasis deserves scrutiny. Reliable feedstock for smelters can support jobs and downstream manufacturing, but a policy designed around keeping processing plants supplied may also increase pressure to explore and extract more material. The decision alone does not demonstrate that this will happen. Actual consequences depend on later permit decisions, fiscal instruments, extraction volumes and environmental approvals.
The new decision can inform mining governance and trade, fiscal policy, domestic supply priorities, business licensing, geological research and additional exploration obligations. The previous decision had a three-year duration and review provisions; the replacement allows evaluation when necessary without repeating the same fixed three-year limit. It does not publicly explain, within its operative text, why each of the five commodities was dropped.
Who gains, and who bears the risks?
Manufacturers seeking predictable supplies of nickel, cobalt or copper may benefit from clearer state priorities. Mining operators may use the classification to assess investment opportunities, although profitability depends on ore quality, prices, infrastructure and real permitting decisions rather than the label alone. Provincial authorities must weigh economic opportunities against land use and environmental responsibilities.
For residents near mines and processing sites, the central questions are different: water quality, forest conversion, dust, waste, transport, worker safety, land rights and whether local communities receive lasting benefits. None of those outcomes can be inferred from the classification list. A designation as “critical” is not evidence that extraction in a particular forest or conservation area is lawful or desirable.
The risks also differ by commodity. Mercury presents well-known toxicity concerns, while thorium raises questions about radioactive-material controls. Their removal from this particular list should not be confused with repeal of separate hazardous-substance or radiation regulations. Equally, keeping nickel on the list does not establish that any specific nickel operator has violated environmental law.
What officials and companies still need to show
The government has a legitimate policy interest in securing raw materials for industry and reducing vulnerable import dependencies. Reporting by CNBC Indonesia on 19 November and Tirto on 20 November confirms the new count and the removals. But the published decision is not a cost-benefit study, and these reports do not establish the expected fiscal cost, affected concessions or community impacts.
The questions for ESDM are therefore concrete. What evidence justified removing each commodity? Which existing permits or proposed projects, if any, will be reconsidered because of the new classification? Will officials disclose environmental and social assessments before using the list to support new projects? How will the public verify whether promised local jobs and revenues outweigh rehabilitation and health costs?
Until implementing decisions and project-level records are available, claims that this decree either guarantees industrial success or authorises environmental destruction would go beyond the evidence. The confirmed development is a change in national classification; its practical winners, costs and safeguards remain to be demonstrated.




