Key points
- Taxes, customs and excise made up 80.5 percent of state revenue in 2025 and 78.8 percent through October 2026; VAT is about 44 percent of tax revenue.
- Annual income tax paid by individuals was Rp19.2 trillion through September 2026, against Rp189.4 trillion withheld from employees' pay; there is no wealth tax.
- Spending under scrutiny includes 26 paid Wantimpres members, Rp14.69 billion in ministry contracts with a Raffi Ahmad linked firm, and premium water at an MPR meeting.
- Aksi Kamisan reached its 933rd edition; 13 of 17 Komnas HAM investigated gross rights cases are stalled, the coordinating law minister said.
- The DPR was the least trusted state institution in Indikator's January 2026 survey.
A meme shared widely on Instagram this week sets two photos side by side: an official at a hearing under the words "those who ask for tax", and a young street vendor pushing a food cart under "those who pay tax". It went viral days after Finance Minister Suahasil Nazara asked the public on 13 November 2026 to support the collection of the Rp514 trillion still needed to reach this year's tax target. Comments under such posts repeat the same complaints: the public pays, officials spend, and peaceful protest changes little.
This analysis does not judge those feelings. It sets out what the records show on three questions: who carries the tax burden, how officials' spending has been documented, and how the state has answered public demands. Official responses are included throughout. We have already checked the Rp514 trillion framing and the claim that the rich and officials pay no tax; this piece builds on them.
1. Who carries the tax burden
Taxes fund most of the budget. Through October 2026, tax revenue plus customs and excise reached Rp2,064 trillion out of Rp2,618 trillion in total state revenue, Antara reported from the APBN KiTa briefing on 13 November. That is 78.8 percent by NewsWLD's calculation; the share is lower than usual this year because non-tax revenue, helped by commodity prices, forest enforcement fines and a Bank Indonesia surplus, already reached Rp551.8 trillion, or 120.2 percent of its target. In 2025 the tax share was 80.5 percent (Rp2,217.9 trillion of Rp2,756.3 trillion), according to the Finance Ministry's fiscal policy agency, and the 2026 budget plans 85.4 percent (Rp2,693.7 trillion of Rp3,153.6 trillion). The viral line that "more than 80 percent of state revenue comes from taxes" is therefore true for the 2025 outcome and the 2026 plan, slightly below the mark for 2026 so far, and only true when customs and excise are counted.
Consumption and wages carry a large share. VAT and luxury sales tax brought in Rp793.55 trillion through October 2026, up 39.2 percent, the government communication agency Bakom said; that is 44.2 percent of the Rp1,796.8 trillion in tax revenue, by NewsWLD's calculation. In 2025 the share was 41.2 percent, according to the ministry's fourth quarter APBN KiTa report. Through September 2026, income tax withheld from employees' pay (PPh 21) reached Rp189.4 trillion, while annual income tax paid by individual taxpayers on their own returns was Rp19.2 trillion, according to the ministry's briefing slides. VAT is paid at the same rate by rich and poor shoppers, which is why the economic think tank CELIOS calls it regressive. When a full rise to 12 percent was planned, CELIOS estimated it would add Rp354,000 a month to a middle class household's spending. President Prabowo Subianto then limited the effective 12 percent rate to luxury goods from 1 January 2025, the Cabinet Secretariat said; other goods stayed at an effective 11 percent.
Small businesses have a light regime. Under Government Regulation (PP) 20 of 2026, individual micro, small and medium businesses pay no income tax on annual turnover up to Rp500 million, and a final 0.5 percent of turnover between Rp500 million and Rp4.8 billion, with no end date for individuals, the Directorate General of Taxes (DJP) said. A street vendor like the one in the meme is very unlikely to owe income tax, though he pays VAT on many goods he buys and regional taxes and levies.
The wealthy: income taxed, wealth not. Indonesia's tax ratio, including customs and excise, was 9.31 percent of GDP in 2025, Bisnis reported. CELIOS, in its two year report card on the Prabowo government released on 12 October 2026, proposed a 1 to 2 percent annual tax on individuals with net wealth above Rp84 billion, which it estimates could raise Rp142.2 trillion a year. Director General of Taxes Bimo Wijayanto said at a DJP media gathering in Bogor on 12 November that "there is indeed no taxation of wealth yet", that the concepts of wealth, income and assets must be studied, and that wealth is "an accumulation of assets from income that has already been taxed", Pikiran Rakyat and CNBC Indonesia reported. He said he would support a study if directed and that the ministry's fiscal strategy directorate (DJSEF) is the body to answer. We found no public DJSEF response as of 16 November. As our earlier fact check showed, dividends received by domestic taxpayers are exempt from income tax, and gains on assets that have not been sold are not taxed, so not all wealth has passed through income tax. Our claim check rates Bimo's statement partly true.
2. Official spending under scrutiny
Budget cuts and where they fell. Presidential Instruction (Inpres) 1 of 2025 ordered Rp306.69 trillion in savings: Rp256.1 trillion from ministries and agencies and Rp50.59 trillion from transfers to regions, according to the instruction. It told agencies to cut ceremonies, studies, seminars, publications and official travel. The Public Works Ministry lost the most, Rp81.38 trillion, Kompas reported.
Parliament's allowances. The August 2025 protests began over a Rp50 million monthly housing allowance for members of the House of Representatives (DPR). Deputy Speaker Sufmi Dasco Ahmad announced on 5 September 2025 that it would stop from 31 August 2025, and the DPR published a take home pay of Rp65,595,730 a month after cuts to other allowances, detikcom reported.
A larger advisory council. Prabowo installed 26 members of the Presidential Advisory Council (Wantimpres) on 2 October 2026 under Presidential Decree 107/P of 2026, the State Secretariat said. The 2006 law allowed a chair and eight members; Law 64 of 2024 removed the cap. Under Presidential Regulation 15 of 2026, each member receives Rp76.5 million a month plus ministerial facilities, which economist Achmad Nur Hidayat put at about Rp23.87 billion a year for the 26 members, Investor.id reported. A citizen asked the Constitutional Court on 15 October 2026 to review the missing cap, Antara reported.
Influencer contracts. Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) said on 9 November 2026 that two ministries signed eight procurement packages worth Rp14.69 billion with PT Rans Animasi Indonesia, linked to presenter Raffi Ahmad, who is also a special presidential envoy: Rp3.9 billion from the education and culture ministry in 2024 and Rp10.79 billion from the Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Ministry in 2025 and 2026. RANS said the work followed procurement rules, used its commercial rate card and covered production, travel and events, not only posts, Katadata reported.
Water on the table, water in the bottle. Photos from the MPR joint meeting on 13 November 2026, which prepared the replacement of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, show green glass bottles on the table, detikcom's photo gallery shows. Social media users identified them as Equil, a premium local brand, and compared them with a video of pupils at SD YPPK Bibikem in Merauke, South Papua, drinking murky reservoir water. The retail price quoted in viral posts is a supermarket price, not a procurement record; we found no MPR procurement document or Secretariat General statement on the bottles. The Finance Ministry's 2026 cost standards (PMK 32 of 2025) cap meeting food at Rp118,000 per person plus Rp53,000 for snacks for ministerial level meetings. In Bibikem, a teacher told detikcom the government built borehole has not worked for over a year, and South Papua Governor Apolo Safanpo said on 11 November he would send agencies to check. In 2024, 71.9 percent of South Papua households had access to safe drinking water, against 92.64 percent nationally, according to BPS data reported by Databoks.
Flexing and accountability. The best known lifestyle case remains former tax official Rafael Alun Trisambodo, sentenced to 14 years for gratification and money laundering, a sentence upheld on appeal, detikcom reported. After his son's assault case exposed the family's lifestyle in 2023, the civil service ministry said civil servants who flaunt wealth face sanctions, Kompas reported.
3. Are aspirations heard?
Aksi Kamisan. Families of victims of past rights abuses have stood silently with black umbrellas across from the Merdeka Palace every Thursday since 18 January 2007. The 933rd edition, on 12 November 2026, marked 28 years since the Semanggi I shootings and urged the Attorney General to act on Komnas HAM files, ANTARA Foto reported. The state has responded in some ways. President Joko Widodo received participants at the palace on 31 May 2018, during the 540th action, and ordered the Attorney General to coordinate with Komnas HAM, BBC Indonesia reported. On 11 January 2023 he acknowledged 12 gross rights violations on behalf of the state and launched a non judicial remedy programme, Kompaspedia records. But the families' central demand, trials, has largely not been met. Coordinating Minister for Law and Human Rights Yusril Ihza Mahendra said on 9 November 2026 that 13 of the 17 events investigated by Komnas HAM are stalled because the commission and the Attorney General's Office disagree on evidence, and announced a working group led by deputy minister Otto Hasibuan, Bakom said. Only four have reached a rights court; in the latest, the Supreme Court on 13 November 2026 overturned the 2022 acquittal in the Paniai case and sentenced the only defendant to five years, Monitor Indonesia reported. In November 2025 the government named former president Soeharto a national hero, a decision Kamisan participants had protested, Tirto reported.
The 17+8 demands. After the August 2025 unrest, a civil society coalition set 17 demands due by 5 September 2025 and 8 due by 31 August 2026. Deputy State Secretary Juri Ardiantoro said on 6 September 2025: "Everything will be followed up. Don't ask when," Kompas reported. The independent tracker bijakmemantau.id then counted three short term demands met, 11 started, three moving backwards and eight ignored, Kompas reported; Tempo later reported that only three long term demands, on DPR reform, tax reform and the asset forfeiture bill, were in progress. Bakom told BBC Indonesia in August 2026 that aspirations "do not stop at being heard and noted" and pointed to a new wage regulation (PP 49 of 2025), a commission on police reform and the president's support for the asset forfeiture bill. Our fact check rates the "everything followed up" pledge misleading.
Protest policing. The August 2025 unrest left 11 dead, Komnas HAM said, and police data cited by rights bodies show at least 2,093 children were arrested (our accountability review). At the 27 August 2026 protest in Jakarta, police said they detained 322 people, 160 of them children, and named 48 suspects over damage, assault and carrying sharp weapons, according to the Advocacy Team for Democracy (TAUD), which counted 387 detained in total and one elderly vendor beaten to death nearby. After the 10 November 2026 protests in Yogyakarta, KontraS, citing LBH Yogyakarta, said 47 people were detained and 13 were unaccounted for at the time, Suara.com reported; police in Yogyakarta denied entering the Gadjah Mada University campus.
Trust. The DPR was the least trusted state institution in Indikator Politik Indonesia's January 2026 survey, with 56 percent trust, Telusur reported. At a DPR forum on 12 November 2026, lawmaker Hetifah Sjaifudian said "the public does not always see the DPR the way the DPR sees itself" and called for closing the loop on public input, IDN Times reported.
What people say
"Our demands were never heard, let alone realised," factory worker turned ride hailing driver Jumhar told BBC Indonesia a year after the August 2025 protests. A university student at the 12 November Kamisan, Megha Maharani, told NU Online she hoped the weekly vigil could one day end "because justice has been achieved". The government's position, in Bakom's words to BBC Indonesia, is that it "keeps opening space for dialogue" so relevant aspirations feed into policy.
What to watch
- Whether the November and December tax push relies on wages and VAT or on new measures for high wealth, and whether DJSEF answers the wealth tax question.
- The Constitutional Court's handling of the Wantimpres petition and any audit of the RANS contracts, which ICW asked BPKP to carry out.
- Whether Yusril's working group moves any of the 13 stalled rights cases to investigation.
- Komnas HAM's findings, if any, on the 27 August and 10 November 2026 protests.
Sources
- 1.Antara: Menkeu: Defisit APBN per Oktober 2026 on track, antaranews.com
- 2.Bakom: Pendapatan Negara Tumbuh 24 Persen Per Oktober, bakom.go.id
- 3.DJSEF Kemenkeu: APBN 2025 Tunjukkan Kinerja yang Solid, fiskal.kemenkeu.go.id
- 4.Kemenkeu: APBN KiTa Q4 2025, media.kemenkeu.go.id
- 5.Bisnis: Penerimaan Pajak Sudah 68% dari Target per September 2026, ekonomi.bisnis.com
- 6.Kemenkeu: Konferensi Pers APBN KiTa Oktober 2026 (data per September), media.kemenkeu.go.id
- 7.CELIOS: 12% VAT, a severe blow to Gen Z and the lower middle class, celios.co.id
- 8.Setkab: Presiden Prabowo: PPN 12% Hanya Barang dan Jasa Mewah, setkab.go.id
- 9.DJP: PP 20/2026, Tarif PPh 0,5% bagi UMKM Orang Pribadi Berlaku Selamanya, pajak.go.id
- 10.Bisnis: Tax Ratio 2025 Turun Jadi 9,31%, ekonomi.bisnis.com
- 11.Pikiran Rakyat: DJP Buka Suara soal Pajak Orang Super Kaya, pikiran-rakyat.com
- 12.CNBC Indonesia: Bos Pajak Buka Suara soal Usulan Pajak Kekayaan, cnbcindonesia.com
- 13.JDIH Kemenkeu: Inpres 1 Tahun 2025, jdih.kemenkeu.go.id
- 14.Kompas: 5 Kementerian dan Lembaga dengan Efisiensi Anggaran Terbesar, money.kompas.com
- 15.detikJogja: Rincian Gaji dan Tunjangan DPR Usai Pemangkasan, detik.com
- 16.Setneg: Usai Dilantik, Anggota Wantimpres Siap Berikan Pertimbangan, setneg.go.id
- 17.Investor.id: 26 Wantimpres Prabowo, Berapa Ongkos yang Ditanggung Negara?, investor.id
- 18.Antara: Pakar: Penentuan jumlah Wantimpres kebolehan konstitusional Presiden, antaranews.com
- 19.Katadata: Disorot ICW soal Kontrak Rp14,69 M, RANS Buka Suara, katadata.co.id
- 20.Kompas: Rp 14.7 Billion for Influencers, Citizens Asked to Save, go.kompas.com
- 21.detikcom: MPR Gelar Rapat Gabungan Usai Gibran Mundur (foto), news.detik.com
- 22.DJKN: PMK 32 Tahun 2025 tentang Standar Biaya Masukan TA 2026, djkn.kemenkeu.go.id
- 23.detikSulsel: Air Keruh Jadi Pelepas Dahaga Siswa-Guru di Merauke, detik.com
- 24.Bataspapua: Gubernur Apolo Safanpo Respons Krisis Air Bersih di Bibikem, bataspapua.com
- 25.Databoks: Rumah Tangga dengan Akses Sumber Air Minum Layak 2024, databoks.katadata.co.id
- 26.detikcom: Rafael Alun Tetap Divonis 14 Tahun Penjara, news.detik.com
- 27.Kompas: Menpan-RB: Ada Sanksi bagi ASN yang Pamer Harta, nasional.kompas.com
- 28.ANTARA Foto: The 933rd Kamisan Action in Jakarta, antarafoto.com
- 29.BBC Indonesia: Jokowi bertemu demonstran Kamisan (2018), bbc.com
- 30.Kompaspedia: Aksi Kamisan, Sejarah dan Perjuangan Melawan Lupa, kompaspedia.kompas.id
- 31.Bakom: Pemerintah Bentuk Tim Khusus Koordinasi Kejaksaan-Komnas HAM, bakom.go.id
- 32.Monitor Indonesia: Yusril Akui 13 Kasus Pelanggaran HAM Berat Masih Mandek, monitorindonesia.com
- 33.Monitor Indonesia: Putusan Kasasi Paniai, monitorindonesia.com
- 34.Setkab: Presiden Prabowo Anugerahkan Gelar Pahlawan Nasional 2025, setkab.go.id
- 35.Tirto: Massa Aksi Kamisan Serukan Tolak Soeharto Jadi Pahlawan Nasional, tirto.id
- 36.Kompas: Istana Pastikan 17+8 Tuntutan Rakyat Akan Ditindaklanjuti, nasional.kompas.com
- 37.Kompas: Daftar 17+8 Tuntutan Rakyat yang Telah Dipenuhi, kompas.com
- 38.Tempo: Apa Saja Tuntutan Rakyat 17+8 yang Sudah dan Belum Terpenuhi?, tempo.co
- 39.BBC Indonesia: Setahun demo Agustus 2025, bbc.com
- 40.KontraS/TAUD: Segera Bebaskan Seluruh Korban Penangkapan Sewenang-wenang (31 Aug 2026), kontras.org
- 41.Suara.com: 47 Orang Ditahan, KontraS Soroti Demo Yogya, suara.com
- 42.Telusur: Survei Indikator, DPR Jadi Lembaga Paling Tidak Dipercaya, telusur.co.id
- 43.IDN Times: DPR Now 2026, idntimes.com
- 44.NU Online: Aksi Kamisan 12 November 2026, jakarta.nu.or.id




