Key points
- Presidential, DPR and regional head candidates need only high school; ministers have no education requirement.
- On the government's Karirhub portal, 7.1% of 88,532 vacancies in 2025 were for university graduates, but a World Bank study found most English-language online job ads that state a requirement ask for a degree.
- BPS counted 7.38 million unemployed in August 2026; unemployment was highest among SMK (8.20%) and SMA (6.87%) graduates; informal work rose to 57.93%.
- About 16 people applied for each of 250,407 CPNS posts in 2024; the CAT test was breached by a paid remote-access syndicate in 2021.
- Courts convicted the regents of Pati, Ponorogo, Klaten, Nganjuk, Probolinggo and Pemalang in job-selling or post-related bribery cases.
- TII found 165 of 562 BUMN commissioner seats held by politicians and volunteers, and 30 deputy ministers still sitting as commissioners in 2026.
A candidate for president, the House of Representatives (DPR) or a governorship in Indonesia needs only a senior high school diploma. Many of the people who vote for them face a harder gate when they look for work: degree filters and age limits in job ads, a civil service test with roughly 16 applicants per post, and back doors into public jobs that court records show have been sold.
This analysis follows up our fact check of a viral Lambe Turah post, which found the officials' side of the post accurate but said the slogan "the people must have a degree" goes too far as a description of civil service rules. Readers told us that misses how the job market feels. We went back to the data on vacancies, unemployment and public sector hiring to test that.
The double standard is in the law
The minimum education to run for president, vice president, the DPR, the Regional Representative Council (DPD), regional councils or regional head is senior high school under the Elections Law and the Regional Elections Law. Ministers have no education requirement at all, and village heads need junior high school. The Constitutional Court (MK) refused to raise the bar to a degree on 29 September 2025. By Statistics Indonesia's (BPS) count, 63 of the 580 House members elected in 2024 list high school as their highest education.
Inside the bureaucracy the bar is higher. Senior executive posts require at least a bachelor's degree or D-IV under Government Regulation 11 of 2017, and most posts at a ministry such as Religious Affairs in the 2024 civil service (CPNS) intake were for diploma or degree holders.
Do most job ads demand a degree? It depends which ads
There is no official, nationally representative count of job vacancies by education requirement in Indonesia, so the answer depends on which ads are counted.
On the government's own job portal, Karirhub, most openings are not for graduates. Of 88,532 vacancies posted in 2025, 44.1% were aimed at senior high school graduates, 28.1% at vocational school (SMK) graduates, 13.2% at diploma holders and only 7.1% (6,287) at university graduates, the Manpower Ministry's SPARK 2025 report shows. Yet university graduates made up 23.1% of the 986,745 job seekers registered on the same portal. For graduates, the squeeze is a shortage of graduate jobs as much as a degree filter.
Office and professional jobs advertised online look different. A World Bank study of 175,255 English-language online job postings collected from December 2019 to December 2020 found that about one third stated an education requirement, and of those, "the great majority included a bachelor's degree or an equivalent level of education as a minimum requirement". Postings asked for an average of 3.1 years of experience, and 42% were in Jakarta.
So the complaint that "most job ads want S1" matches the market for white-collar jobs posted online, which is the market many young urban job seekers see. It does not match vacancies as a whole, which are dominated by high school level work. We examine the claim in a separate fact check.
The unemployment numbers behind the frustration
BPS reported on 5 November 2026 that 7.38 million people were unemployed in August 2026, an open unemployment rate of 4.75%, down from 4.85% a year earlier. Unemployment was highest among SMK graduates at 8.20% and senior high school graduates at 6.87%, against 5.09% for holders of a D-IV degree or higher and 2.24% for people with primary school or less, Katadata's summary of the BPS data shows. About 880,430 of the unemployed hold a D-IV, bachelor's or postgraduate degree.
The headline fall hides weaker jobs. The share of workers in the informal sector rose to 57.93% from 57.80%, and the underemployment rate, people working under 35 hours a week who want more work, rose to 8.68% from 7.91%, BPS deputy Edy Mahmud said, detikFinance reported. BPS also said paid participants in the government's MagangHub internship programme count as employed.
Among people aged 15 to 24, 19.44% (8.6 million) were not in education, employment or training (NEET) in 2025, down from 20.31% in 2024, according to BPS data published by the Manpower Ministry. The ministry's own summary notes that the NEET rate tends to be higher among young people with a D-IV or higher degree.
Age limits: the courts and the ministry left the door open
Age caps such as "maximum 25 years" are common in Indonesian job ads. Two challenges at the MK failed. On 30 July 2024 the court rejected a petition by job seeker Leonardo Olefins Hamonangan against Article 35(1) of the Manpower Law, with Justice Guntur Hamzah dissenting that the article creates legal uncertainty for job seekers, BBC News Indonesia reported. In Decision 124/PUU-XXII/2024 the court again refused to ban age requirements, saying they are neither absolutely banned nor absolutely allowed and must rest on the specific needs of the job.
Manpower Minister Yassierli then issued Circular M/6/HK.04/V/2025 on 28 May 2025 banning discrimination in recruitment, but said age limits are "still possible" where the nature of the job genuinely requires them. The circular is addressed to governors and asks employers to improve their practices.
In a KedaiKOPI online survey of 1,213 people aged 17 to 45, conducted 23 to 29 September 2026, 39.2% named age limits as a barrier to finding work. KedaiKOPI said the sample was non-probability and the results describe respondents' views rather than an estimate for all young people.
'Orang dalam': what the evidence shows
The same KedaiKOPI survey found the most cited barrier was needing connections or "orang dalam" (an insider), named by 56% of respondents, ahead of limited jobs (48%) and tough competition (41.3%). "This finding indicates that nepotism or 'orang dalam' practices are still fairly common in recruitment," KedaiKOPI research head Ashma Nur Afifah said, Katadata reported. The survey measures perception, not proof, and covers private as well as public jobs.
For public sector jobs there is harder evidence, and it points to different doors.
The CPNS test. Entry to the civil service runs through the computer assisted test (CAT) run by the National Civil Service Agency (BKN). In 2024, 3,963,832 people applied for 250,407 posts, about 16 applicants per post, according to BKN and the Administrative and Bureaucratic Reform Ministry (KemenPANRB). BKN head Zudan Arif Fakrulloh said on 24 September 2026 that the CAT system "cannot be intervened by anyone" because scores are visible in real time.
That claim has been tested. Police said in April 2022 that a syndicate had used remote access software to take CAT exams for paying candidates in the 2021 intake, at Rp150 juta to Rp600 juta per candidate; 359 participants were disqualified, and the heads of the civil service agencies of two districts were among those named, Kompas reported. In November 2023 a stand-in was caught sitting a CPNS exam for the Attorney General's Office in Lampung, and police named six suspects, Kompas.com reported. Real-time scoring makes some manipulation harder, but these cases show the test has been breached through the people and computers around it.
Honorary staff and PPPK. Many public jobs were filled outside the CAT, through contract and honorary (honorer) staff later given priority in contract civil servant (PPPK) selection. In Enrekang, South Sulawesi, an inspectorate check of 589 PPPK hired in the 2023 round found 64 had used fake honorary employment letters, some with as little as three or four months of service or none at all; the district said it ended their contracts, detikSulsel reported in August 2025. Deputy chair of the House's Commission II Bahtra Banong said in December 2024 that some regional civil service agencies manipulated data so that long-serving honorary staff could not apply while staff with a year's service could.
Buying posts. Courts have convicted several regional heads of selling posts. Pati regent Sudewo was sentenced to 8.5 years on 21 October 2026 by the Semarang anti-corruption court for extortion in filling village official posts, alongside bribery in a railway project; prosecutors said candidates for 601 village posts were charged Rp165 juta to Rp225 juta each. He said at the time he was considering an appeal. Ponorogo regent Sugiri Sancoko was sentenced to 6.5 years on 14 August 2026 for corruption including a Rp900 juta payment to keep a hospital director in post. Earlier convictions include the regents of Klaten (Sri Hartini, 11 years, 2017), Nganjuk (Novi Rahman Hidayat, 7 years, 2022), Probolinggo (Puput Tantriana Sari, 4 years, upheld by the Supreme Court) and Pemalang (Mukti Agung Wibowo, 6.5 years, 2023). In June 2026 the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) also arrested ten people in an operation over alleged bribery for posts in Kuantan Singingi, Riau, and urged the regent and regional secretary to surrender; no court has ruled in that case.
What civil servants say. In the KPK's 2025 Integrity Assessment Survey, internal respondents said nepotism in promotions and transfers worked through kinship (32%), closeness to officials (33%) and shared alma mater or organisation (23%). The share reporting outside influence over decisions on recruiting non-civil-servant staff, promotions, rotations and training in regional governments doubled to 20% from 10% the year before, the KPK said.
The watchdog that was removed. The Civil Service Commission (KASN), an independent body that monitored merit in appointments, estimated in January 2017 that the trade in civil service posts was worth Rp35 trillion a year across 600 agencies, Liputan6 reported. In March 2019 its chair said more than 90% of ministries were suspected of the practice at some level; the then administrative reform minister Syafruddin "strongly" denied it, Antara reported. The 2023 civil service law abolished KASN, and in 2024 its duties passed to KemenPANRB, which sets merit policy, and BKN, which now supervises it. BKN said it had issued 6,881 recommendations on 64,338 transfer proposals by 1 June 2026. Critics had warned earlier that folding the commission into ministries would weaken independent oversight, Tirto reported.
BUMN boardrooms. For the best-paid public posts, the route is appointment, not a test. Transparency International Indonesia (TII) mapped 562 commissioner posts at 59 state-owned enterprises (BUMN) and 60 subsidiaries in September 2025 and found 165 held by politicians, including party members and political volunteers, with Gerindra, the party chaired by President Prabowo Subianto, accounting for 53 party seats. TII counted 33 deputy ministers sitting as BUMN commissioners in 2025 and 30 in 2026, even though the MK ruled on 28 August 2025 that deputy ministers may not hold such posts and gave the government until 28 August 2027 to comply. TII and CELIOS said at least seven deputy ministers were made commissioners after that ruling. The Ombudsman had already flagged 397 BUMN commissioners with potential dual posts in 2019 data.
The government's answer has been partial. Danantara chief executive Rosan Roeslani said in August 2025 that bonuses (tantiem) for commissioners had been scrapped and boards cut to at most six members, following Prabowo's order. TII said in September 2025 that the number of commissioner posts had not in fact fallen. Muhammad Qodari, then head of the Government Communication Agency, defended appointing people from varied backgrounds, saying they bring "a new perspective", but did not give a timetable for ending deputy ministers' dual posts, DW reported.
What this adds up to
The data supports part of the frustration and refines another part. Degree requirements dominate the online office jobs that many young people chase, but most vacancies nationwide are for high school level work, and those graduates have the highest unemployment. The CPNS test is the most open public door, but it is narrow, about 16 applicants per post in 2024, and it has been cheated. The doors that bypass the test, honorary hiring, village posts, promotions and boardroom appointments, are where court records, KPK surveys and TII's counts show connections and money at work.
The rule that lets a high school graduate become president is a choice lawmakers have kept. The House is drafting a new elections bill targeted for March 2027, and one Commission II leader has proposed a degree requirement for legislative candidates. No proposal has yet addressed the other side of the gap: how jobs in the state and its companies are filled.
Sources
- 1.BPS: TPT Agustus 2026 sebesar 4,75 persen (5 Nov 2026), bps.go.id
- 2.Katadata Databoks: Persentase pengangguran Agustus 2026 menurut pendidikan, databoks.katadata.co.id
- 3.Journal Arta: Pengangguran sarjana 880,43 ribu pada Agustus 2026, journalarta.com
- 4.detikFinance: BPS klaim pengangguran turun, tapi makin banyak yang jadi ojol (5 Nov 2026), finance.detik.com
- 5.Kemnaker: SPARK 2025 Nasional (Karirhub data), paskerid.kemnaker.go.id
- 6.World Bank: Indonesia's Online Vacancy Outlook (2021), documents1.worldbank.org
- 7.Satudata Kemnaker: Mengenal NEET di Indonesia (6 Nov 2026), satudata.kemnaker.go.id
- 8.BBC News Indonesia: MK tolak gugatan diskriminasi usia dalam lowongan kerja, bbc.com
- 9.MK: Penetapan batas usia dalam rekrutmen harus proporsional dan relevan (124/PUU-XXII/2024), mkri.id
- 10.Kemnaker: Menaker terbitkan SE larangan diskriminasi dalam rekrutmen (28 May 2025), kemnaker.go.id
- 11.Katadata Databoks: Survei KedaiKOPI hambatan pemuda cari kerja (21 Oct 2026), databoks.katadata.co.id
- 12.BKN: Jumlah pelamar CPNS 2024 capai 3,9 juta, bkn.go.id
- 13.KemenPANRB: Tersedia 250.407 formasi CPNS 2024, menpan.go.id
- 14.BKN: Kepala BKN tegaskan sistem CAT tidak bisa diintervensi (24 Sep 2026), bkn.go.id
- 15.Kompas: Sindikat joki ujian masuk CASN 2021 terbongkar, kompas.id
- 16.Kompas.com: Kasus joki CPNS Kejaksaan di Lampung, regional.kompas.com
- 17.detikSulsel: 64 PPPK Enrekang pakai SK honorer fiktif (Aug 2025), detik.com
- 18.DPR: Pimpinan Komisi II ungkap modus manipulasi data PPPK, emedia.dpr.go.id
- 19.Antara: Bupati Pati Sudewa divonis 8,5 tahun (21 Oct 2026), antaranews.com
- 20.BBC News Indonesia: Sudewo divonis 8,5 tahun, kasus perangkat desa, bbc.com
- 21.Antara Jatim: Sugiri Sancoko divonis 6,5 tahun (14 Aug 2026), jatim.antaranews.com
- 22.detikNews: Bupati Klaten divonis 11 tahun, news.detik.com
- 23.detikJatim: Kepala daerah Jatim ditangkap KPK (Nganjuk, Probolinggo), detik.com
- 24.detikJatim: Kasasi ditolak, Bupati Probolinggo tetap 4 tahun, detik.com
- 25.Antara: Bupati Pemalang dihukum 6,5 tahun, antaranews.com
- 26.CNN Indonesia: KPK ultimatum Bupati dan Sekda Kuansing (30 Jun 2026), cnnindonesia.com
- 27.KPK: Booklet SPI 2025, spi.kpk.go.id
- 28.Liputan6: KASN sebut bisnis jual beli jabatan Rp35 T per tahun (2017), liputan6.com
- 29.Antara: Pemerintah bantah 90 persen K/L jual beli jabatan (2019), antaranews.com
- 30.SE MenPANRB 2024: pengawasan sistem merit pasca pengalihan tugas KASN, peraturan.bpk.go.id
- 31.BKN: Kelola karier 6,7 juta ASN, rekomendasi I-Mut, bkn.go.id
- 32.Kompas.com: Pembubaran KASN jadi legacy buruk (Oct 2023), regional.kompas.com
- 33.Tirto: Pembubaran KASN, serangan balik calo jual beli jabatan?, tirto.id
- 34.TI Indonesia: Komisaris rasa politisi (30 Sep 2025), ti.or.id
- 35.Kompas: 165 kursi komisaris BUMN diisi politisi, kompas.id
- 36.TI Indonesia: Dua putusan MK diabaikan, wamen rangkap komisaris (10 Sep 2026), ti.or.id
- 37.DW Indonesia: Penertiban rangkap jabatan, mengapa seolah diulur? (12 Oct 2026), dw.com
- 38.Ombudsman: 397 komisaris BUMN terindikasi rangkap jabatan, ombudsman.go.id
- 39.Republika: Prabowo perintahkan komisaris dipangkas, Danantara: sudah dilaksanakan, ekonomi.republika.co.id
- 40.Antara: MK tolak syarat capres/caleg/cakada minimal sarjana, antaranews.com
- 41.PasundanNews: Komisi II wacanakan syarat caleg S1, pasundannews.com




