Key points
- Aksi Kamisan has been held every Thursday since 18 January 2007; the 933rd edition was on 12 November 2026.
- Jokowi met participants in 2018 and acknowledged 12 gross rights violations in January 2023.
- Yusril said on 9 November 2026 that 13 of 17 Komnas HAM investigated cases are stalled.
- The Supreme Court sentenced the Paniai defendant to five years on 13 November 2026.
- Verdict: partly true.
The claim
As anger over taxes and officials' spending spread on social media this month, a common line in posts and comments was that peaceful protest gets nowhere in Indonesia: "demo anteng kaya Kamisan gapernah didengar, rusuh salah" (calm protests like Kamisan are never heard, and riots are blamed). The claim is about Aksi Kamisan, the silent Thursday vigil held across from the Merdeka Palace in Jakarta. This check looks at what the record shows about how the state has answered it.
Verdict: partly true. Kamisan has won meetings, a presidential acknowledgement and a non judicial remedy programme, so "never heard" is not accurate. But its central demand, trials for gross human rights violations, remains largely unmet after almost 19 years, which is what the claim's frustration reflects.
What Kamisan is
Families of victims of past rights abuses, led at the start by figures such as Maria Catarina Sumarsih, whose son was shot in the 1998 Semanggi I incident, have stood in black clothes under black umbrellas across from the palace every Thursday since 18 January 2007, Kompaspedia records. The 933rd edition was held on 12 November 2026; it marked 28 years since the Semanggi I shootings and urged the Attorney General to act on files from the National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM), ANTARA Foto reported. (NU Online numbered the same vigil the 993rd; we use ANTARA's count.)
Ways the state has responded
- A palace meeting. President Joko Widodo received Kamisan participants at the palace on 31 May 2018, during the 540th action, and said he would ask the Attorney General to coordinate with Komnas HAM, BBC Indonesia reported.
- A formal acknowledgement. On 11 January 2023, Jokowi acknowledged on behalf of the state that 12 gross human rights violations had occurred and launched a non judicial remedy programme for victims, Kompaspedia records.
- A new working group. Coordinating Minister for Law and Human Rights Yusril Ihza Mahendra said on 9 November 2026 that the government had formed a team to coordinate the Attorney General's Office and Komnas HAM, led by deputy minister Otto Hasibuan, Bakom reported.
- A court ruling. On 13 November 2026, the Supreme Court overturned the 2022 acquittal in the 2014 Paniai shooting case and sentenced the only defendant to five years in prison, Monitor Indonesia reported. Komnas HAM urged the Attorney General to pursue those higher in the chain of command.
Where the demand remains unmet
- Stalled cases. Yusril himself said 13 of the 17 events investigated by Komnas HAM are stalled because the commission and the Attorney General's Office disagree on evidence, Monitor Indonesia reported. Only four have reached a human rights court.
- No deadline. The working group was announced without a public target or timetable, according to Bakom's statement.
- Soeharto. In November 2025 the government named former president Soeharto a national hero, the Cabinet Secretariat said, a decision Kamisan participants had publicly opposed, Tirto reported.
- Voices at the vigil. University student Megha Maharani told NU Online at the 12 November vigil that she hoped Kamisan could one day end "because justice has been achieved".
Is it fair to say riots are blamed?
That second half of the line is a judgement, not a checkable fact. What the record shows is that after the August 2025 unrest, the state both conceded demands, such as stopping the DPR housing allowance, and arrested large numbers of people, including at least 2,093 children, as our accountability review found. We have checked the government's own pledge on the 17+8 demands separately: Were all 17+8 demands followed up?
Why the verdict is partly true
"Never heard" is too absolute: successive governments have met participants, acknowledged past abuses and created remedy schemes, and a court has just convicted a defendant in one case. But being heard and getting what was asked are different things. The families' core demand, that those responsible for gross violations be tried, has been met in very few cases, and the government's own minister calls most cases stalled. The claim captures that gap but overstates it.
What to watch
- Whether Otto Hasibuan's working group moves any of the 13 stalled cases to a formal investigation by the Attorney General.
- Whether the Attorney General acts on Komnas HAM's call to pursue commanders in the Paniai case.
Related: our analysis Who pays, who spends, who listens.
Sources
- 1.ANTARA Foto: The 933rd Kamisan Action in Jakarta, antarafoto.com
- 2.Kompaspedia: Aksi Kamisan, Sejarah dan Perjuangan Melawan Lupa, kompaspedia.kompas.id
- 3.BBC Indonesia: Jokowi bertemu demonstran Kamisan (2018), bbc.com
- 4.Bakom: Pemerintah Bentuk Tim Khusus Koordinasi Kejaksaan-Komnas HAM, bakom.go.id
- 5.Monitor Indonesia: Yusril Akui 13 Kasus Pelanggaran HAM Berat Masih Mandek, monitorindonesia.com
- 6.Monitor Indonesia: Putusan Kasasi Paniai, monitorindonesia.com
- 7.Setkab: Gelar Pahlawan Nasional 2025, setkab.go.id
- 8.Tirto: Massa Aksi Kamisan Serukan Tolak Soeharto Jadi Pahlawan Nasional, tirto.id
- 9.NU Online: Aksi Kamisan 12 November 2026, jakarta.nu.or.id




