Key points
- At least three former graft convicts hold seats won in 2024: Nurdin Halid (DPR), Desy Yusandi (DPRD Banten) and Irman Gusman (DPD); ICW counted 56 ex-graft convicts on 2024 ballots, Perludem 81 in 2019 with eight elected.
- DPR members Satori and Heri Gunawan, KPK suspects since 7 August 2025, were still not detained and still in office on 11 November 2026.
- Documented prison privilege cases run from Sukamiskin 2018 to the Cibinong 'luxury cluster' found by the Ombudsman on 23 September 2026.
- ICW: average graft sentence in 2024 was 3 years 3 months; only about 4.8 percent of Rp330.9 trillion in losses was recovered.
- Silfester Matutina's 2019 final defamation sentence has not been executed while he appeared in public and was named to two state company boards.
A complaint we hear often from readers is that corruption punishment in Indonesia ends where the cameras stop. NewsWLD tested that complaint against court records, election data, prison inspection reports and official statements. The record shows real arrests and convictions. It also shows a system where convicted officials return to parliament, sitting legislators named as suspects keep their seats for more than a year, prison staff sell comfort to graft convicts, sentences are short and remission rules were loosened, and a final court verdict against a politically connected campaigner has gone unexecuted for about seven years.
This piece follows up our earlier analysis, Prabowo vowed to chase corruptors to Antarctica. What the record shows, which readers told us leaned too heavily on official enforcement figures.
From prison back to parliament
Indonesian law lets former convicts, including graft convicts, run for office. The Constitutional Court in ruling 87/PUU-XX/2022 set the main condition: a former convict must wait five years after finishing a prison term and must openly declare the conviction, Perludem's summary of the ruling says. Calls by civil society to bar graft convicts outright have not become law.
The numbers are not large, but they are persistent. Perludem counted 81 former graft convicts on the ballot in 2019, and eight were elected, including Desy Yusandi to the Banten provincial council and Abdullah Puteh to the Regional Representative Council (DPD), Kompas reported. For 2024, Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) found 56 former graft convicts on the final candidate lists: 27 for the House (DPR), 22 for regional councils and seven for the DPD, according to Kompas.
At least three of them won seats that they hold now:
- Nurdin Halid (Golkar), sentenced by the Supreme Court to two years in prison in 2007 over the Bulog cooking oil distribution case, won a DPR seat in South Sulawesi II with 70,681 votes, Republika reported, and was sworn in for 2024 to 2029.
- Desy Yusandi (Golkar), convicted in 2016 over the Tangerang Selatan health centre construction case, was re-elected to the Banten provincial council, Kompas reported.
- Irman Gusman, the former DPD speaker convicted of bribery, won a DPD seat for West Sumatra after a court-ordered revote in July 2024, Kompas and Antara reported.
In regional elections, ICW said 138 candidates in the 2024 regional head contests had some link to corruption cases, ranging from suspects and defendants to convicts and people named in trials. NewsWLD did not find a nationwide count of how many of them won.
Suspects who keep their seats
The gap is wider for sitting legislators under investigation. The Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) named DPR members Satori (NasDem) and Heri Gunawan (Gerindra) suspects on 7 August 2025 in the Bank Indonesia and OJK social fund (CSR) case, Antara reported. Both remain DPR members for 2024 to 2029. As of 11 November 2026, more than 15 months later, the KPK had not detained either man, Tribunnews reported, citing KPK's suspicion that the two received a total of Rp28.38 billion. Both are presumed innocent.
The parliamentary watchdog Formappi has asked the House ethics council (MKD) to suspend them. The rules give the MKD little to work with: Article 244 of the MD3 Law suspends a DPR member only once he becomes a defendant in a special crimes case such as corruption, not while he is a suspect. NewsWLD found no MKD decision on the two. KPK enforcement deputy Asep Guntur Rahayu said on 2 June 2026 that the delay in detaining them was not caused by political pressure, Tribunnews reported, and the KPK says tracing the money and assets has been the main challenge. Formappi researcher Lucius Karus said that explanation no longer made sense after more than a year.
Luxury behind bars: the same pattern, eight years apart
Readers' second point, that arrests mean little when convicts live comfortably inside, is backed by a chain of documented cases, each followed by promises of reform.
- Sukamiskin, 2018. The KPK caught the head of Sukamiskin prison, Wahid Husen, taking bribes from inmate Fahmi Darmawansyah, a convicted briber, including a Mitsubishi Triton. In return Fahmi got a better cell, phone use and permission to leave. Wahid was sentenced to eight years in 2019, BBC News Indonesia reported. Two months after the arrest, in September 2018, the Ombudsman still found graft convicts' cells left unlocked and larger and better furnished than others.
- Setya Novanto, 2019. The former House speaker, serving a sentence for the e-KTP graft case, was photographed at a building supply store in Padalarang with his wife during a hospital leave in June 2019, Detik reported. He was moved to the maximum security Gunung Sindur prison.
- KPK's own jail, 2019 to 2023. Fifteen KPK detention staff extorted Rp6.3 billion from detainees in exchange for phones and other privileges between May 2019 and May 2023. The Jakarta Corruption Court sentenced them to four to five years on 13 December 2024, Detik reported, and the KPK dismissed 66 staff over the scheme, Kompas reported.
- Cibinong, 2026. On 23 September 2026 the Ombudsman found a "luxury cluster" at Cibinong prison in Bogor: more than ten houses with apartment-style facilities, a gym, a pool and a golf simulator under construction, on the bank of the Ciliwung river. The Immigration and Corrections Ministry (Imipas) inspectorate said one man seen trying to slip away during the inspection was Jimmy Masrin, who is serving ten years for corruption in the LPEI credit case, and that the liquor found belonged to him, Detik reported. The inspectorate found the buildings were unlicensed, not funded by the state budget and not recorded as state assets, and called it abuse of authority.
The ministry's response was quick. It demolished ten buildings on 30 September, dismissed the prison head from the civil service and sanctioned 17 officials, Kompas reported. Sukamiskin removed air conditioners and wood panelling from common areas after a 24 September instruction from the corrections director general. Corrections chief Mashudi has said all inmates are treated the same. Trisakti University criminal law expert Abdul Fickar Hadjar said administrative sanctions were not enough and the case should be taken to criminal court to deter repeats. NewsWLD found no report of a criminal investigation into who built and paid for the Cibinong houses as of mid November 2026.
Short sentences, small recoveries
The sentences themselves are light. ICW's latest sentencing report, released on 4 December 2025 and covering 2024, found the average prison term for corruption defendants was 3 years 3 months, with an average fine of Rp180 million, Kompas reported. Of Rp330.9 trillion in state losses calculated in those verdicts, only Rp16.58 trillion, about 4.8 percent, was recovered through replacement payments. Only 63.56 percent of defendants were ordered to repay, only a quarter were charged with money laundering, 70 were acquitted and only 110 of 1,869 defendants were legislators, regional heads or state company officials. ICW also said more than half of the 3,605 corruption verdicts recorded that year were not published in the Supreme Court's directory.
Earlier exits
The road out of prison also got shorter. In October 2021 the Supreme Court struck down the provision of Government Regulation 99/2012 that required graft convicts to act as justice collaborators before getting remission or parole, Kompas reported. The 2022 Corrections Law then set the same terms for all inmates. On 6 September 2022, 23 graft convicts were paroled on a single day, including former prosecutor Pinangki Sirna Malasari and former Banten governor Ratu Atut Chosiyah, Kompas reported.
Setya Novanto, sentenced to 15 years, had his term cut to 12 years 6 months by a Supreme Court review in June 2025, received 28 months and 15 days of remission and walked out on parole on 16 August 2025, the corrections directorate told Antara. On Independence Day 2026, 303 graft convicts in West Java and 83 in Banten received remission, according to regional corrections offices quoted by Kompas and BantenNews.
Pardons from the top
The most visible exits came from the president. On 1 August 2025 Prabowo granted amnesty to PDI-P secretary general Hasto Kristiyanto, sentenced to 3.5 years for bribery in the Harun Masiku case, and abolition to former trade minister Tom Lembong, sentenced to 4.5 years in the sugar import case, after the DPR approved both. Law Minister Supratman Andi Agtas said the aim was unity and reconciliation. ICW researcher Yassar Aulia told BBC News Indonesia that, as far as ICW knew, no graft convict had ever received amnesty or abolition before, and warned it set a bad precedent. Neither verdict was final. In December 2024 Prabowo had told students in Cairo that corruptors who returned what they stole "might be forgiven", Kompas reported, a remark his coordinating minister Yusril Ihza Mahendra later described as an asset recovery strategy.
The asset forfeiture bill, which civil society has demanded for more than a decade, is finally moving. Commission III member Nasir Djamil said on 10 November 2026 that deliberation was in its final stage and a drafting team would be formed, DPR's media unit reported. It has not been passed.
A verdict that has waited seven years
Enforcement gaps also show up beyond corruption cases, when the person involved is politically connected. Silfester Matutina, chairman of the volunteer group Solidaritas Merah Putih and a deputy chair of the Prabowo-Gibran campaign team in 2024, was sentenced by the Supreme Court in 2019 (ruling 287 K/Pid/2019) to 1 year 6 months for defaming former vice president Jusuf Kalla. The sentence has never been carried out.
He has not been hard to see. On 4 August 2025 he spoke to reporters at Jakarta police headquarters after being questioned as a witness, saying he had "no problem" if he were jailed, Kompas reported. He was appointed an independent commissioner of state food company ID Food in 2025 and of state port services firm Pelindo Jasa Maritim on 18 September 2026, before Pelindo dismissed him five days later, Tirto reported. Yet prosecutors have said they cannot find him. The Attorney General's Office said on 31 December 2025 it was still searching, and in January 2026 NasDem legislator Machfud Arifin asked the Attorney General in a hearing: "Who is Silfester? Not brave enough?" Kompas reported. On 25 September 2026 the office's spokesman Anang Supriatna said execution was "fully the authority" of the South Jakarta prosecutors and that it would coordinate further, Sindonews reported. A former South Jakarta chief prosecutor said in 2025 that the order was issued after the verdict but Silfester "went missing" and then the pandemic came, and denied political pressure, Detik reported.
What would close the gaps
Civil society groups point to concrete fixes: barring graft convicts from office or lengthening the waiting period, letting the MKD suspend members once they are named suspects, criminal prosecution of prison officials who sell privileges, publishing every corruption verdict, passing the asset forfeiture law, and limits on amnesty and abolition for corruption. None of these is in force today. Until they are, the record supports readers who say that punishment for the powerful too often looks like a formality.
Sources
- 1.Kompas: Infografik 56 bekas terpidana korupsi masuk DCT, kompas.com
- 2.Kompas: KPU diminta atur masa jeda eks koruptor (Perludem 2019 data), nasional.kompas.com
- 3.Perludem: Putusan MK 87/PUU-XX/2022, perludem.or.id
- 4.Republika: Mantan terpidana kasus korupsi terpilih jadi anggota DPR, news.republika.co.id
- 5.Kompas: Satu caleg mantan napi korupsi kembali jadi anggota DPRD Banten, regional.kompas.com
- 6.Kompas: KPU tetapkan eks koruptor Irman Gusman lolos DPD, nasional.kompas.com
- 7.Antara: KPK panggil anggota DPR Satori, antaranews.com
- 8.Tribunnews: Kasus CSR BI-OJK belum tuntas, tribunnews.com
- 9.Pasal 244 UU 17/2014 (MD3), pasal.id
- 10.BBC Indonesia: Eks Kalapas Sukamiskin divonis delapan tahun, bbc.com
- 11.Ombudsman: Lapas Sukamiskin belum berbenah (2018), ombudsman.go.id
- 12.Detik: Novanto pelesiran ke toko bangunan Padalarang, news.detik.com
- 13.Detik: Vonis 15 terdakwa pungli Rutan KPK, news.detik.com
- 14.Kompas: KPK pecat 66 pegawai pungli rutan, nasional.kompas.com
- 15.Ombudsman: Kluster mewah Lapas Cibinong, ombudsman.go.id
- 16.CNN Indonesia: Investigasi sementara Imipas Lapas Cibinong, cnnindonesia.com
- 17.Detik: Napi kabur saat sidak Ombudsman adalah Jimmy Masrin, news.detik.com
- 18.Kompas: Pembongkaran fasilitas mewah Lapas Cibinong dinilai tak selesaikan masalah, nasional.kompas.com
- 19.Kompas: Lapas Sukamiskin bersih-bersih fasilitas, bandung.kompas.com
- 20.Kompas: Potret suram pemidanaan korupsi 2024 (ICW), nasional.kompas.com
- 21.Kompas.id: Vonis korupsi 2024 temuan ICW, kompas.id
- 22.Kompas: MA cabut PP 99/2012, nasional.kompas.com
- 23.Kompas: 23 koruptor bebas bersyarat 6 September 2022, nasional.kompas.com
- 24.Antara: Setnov dapat remisi 28 bulan sebelum bebas bersyarat, antaranews.com
- 25.Kompas: 20.500 napi di Jabar terima remisi HUT ke-81, bandung.kompas.com
- 26.BantenNews: 83 koruptor terima remisi HUT RI ke-81, bantennews.co.id
- 27.BBC Indonesia: Tom Lembong dan Hasto bebas, bbc.com
- 28.CNN Indonesia: Alasan Prabowo beri abolisi dan amnesti, cnnindonesia.com
- 29.Kompas: Kembalikan yang kau curi, mungkin kita maafkan, nasional.kompas.com
- 30.Kompas: Yusril sebut pernyataan Prabowo strategi pemulihan aset, nasional.kompas.com
- 31.DPR: Pembahasan RUU Perampasan Aset masuki tahap akhir, emedia.dpr.go.id
- 32.Kompas: Silfester siap ditahan, di Polda Metro Jaya, megapolitan.kompas.com
- 33.Tirto: Silfester 5 hari jadi komisaris Pelindo JM, tirto.id
- 34.Kompas: Anggota DPR kritik Kejagung belum tangkap Silfester, nasional.kompas.com
- 35.Sindonews: Kejagung buka suara soal eksekusi Silfester, nasional.sindonews.com
- 36.Detik: Eks Kajari Jaksel ungkap alasan Silfester tak dieksekusi, news.detik.com




