JERUSALEM, November 18, 2026, The US-backed Board of Peace overseeing the Gaza ceasefire has warned that both Israel and Hamas have failed to carry out crucial commitments, jeopardising a truce that began in October 2025. Its 12-page report to the UN Security Council, reviewed by Reuters and reported separately by the Associated Press, describes a widening gap between the diplomatic agreement and conditions on the ground.
The assessment is significant because it comes from the body established under President Donald Trump's peace framework, rather than solely from one of the parties to the conflict. It is an assessment of compliance, not an announcement that the ceasefire has formally ended.
Where the plan has stalled
The wider arrangement envisages Hamas relinquishing its weapons and governing role, the establishment of a transitional civilian administration, Israeli troop withdrawals and reconstruction. Reuters reports that Hamas accepted a Board of Peace roadmap in July to transfer governance and surrender arms, but Israel rejected that sequence, insisting Hamas must first be dismantled.
According to the report, Israeli strikes have continued while Hamas fighters have also engaged in military activity. The board argues that each side's failure obstructs implementation by the other. The Associated Press reports that the board urged the Security Council to press both parties to meet their obligations rather than use the other's delays as justification.
Civilian administration and aid
The report criticises Israeli authorities for failing to approve arrangements for a Palestinian civilian police force and an interim technocratic administration. Those decisions are tied to an international stabilisation force, troop withdrawals and the start of reconstruction.
It also says Israeli restrictions on supplies and equipment, together with funding shortages, have undermined preparations for winter flooding. Displaced families remain in tents and damaged buildings. Separately, the report alleges that taxes collected by Hamas on incoming goods have affected the availability of basic commodities.
These are findings attributed to the board's report; they should not be confused with independently adjudicated legal conclusions.
Reactions and the next test
Reuters reported that senior Hamas official Basem Naim rejected the assessment as disinformation. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office did not immediately provide a response to Reuters, while Defence Minister Israel Katz reiterated that Israel would not withdraw until Hamas was dismantled and Gaza demilitarised.
The board is expected to bring its findings to the Security Council later in November. Whether that produces concrete decisions on policing, access for aid, disarmament and withdrawal remains unresolved. The warning is that a ceasefire without tangible improvements for civilians may become increasingly difficult to sustain.
Reporting basis: Reuters and Associated Press, November 18, 2026. The full 12-page report was described by those agencies; this article does not claim to have independently obtained the complete document.




