Key points
- Supreme Court ruling 287 K/Pid/2019 sentenced Silfester Matutina to 1 year 6 months; it has not been executed.
- Kejagung said on 31 December 2025 it was still searching; on 25 September 2026 it said execution is up to South Jakarta prosecutors.
- Silfester spoke to reporters on 4 August 2025, served as ID Food commissioner and was named Pelindo Jasa Maritim commissioner on 18 September 2026.
- Nusron Wahid, a witness, skipped KPK summonses on 7 and 15 October 2026, attended a cabinet session on 21 October and was questioned on 4 November.
The claim: Social media users and readers say prosecutors claim it is hard to catch Silfester Matutina, even though he is seen at public meetings, and that Minister Nusron Wahid gets the same treatment.
Verdict: Partly true. The Silfester part holds up. Prosecutors have said for more than a year that they cannot locate him to carry out a final 2019 prison sentence, while he appeared before reporters, held a seat on a state company board and was appointed to another in September 2026. NewsWLD found no credible report of him at an official meeting, and a November 2026 video said to show him at a restaurant opening is unconfirmed. The Nusron part needs context: he is a witness, not a convict or suspect. He skipped two KPK summonses and attended a cabinet session in between, but he was questioned by the KPK on 4 November 2026.
Silfester: a final sentence not carried out
Silfester Matutina, chairman of the volunteer group Solidaritas Merah Putih and a deputy chair of the Prabowo-Gibran national campaign team in 2024, was sentenced by the Supreme Court in 2019 (ruling 287 K/Pid/2019) to 1 year 6 months for defaming former vice president Jusuf Kalla. The verdict is final. It has not been executed.
What prosecutors have said:
- A former South Jakarta chief prosecutor said in August 2025 that an execution order was issued after the verdict, but Silfester "went missing" and then the Covid-19 pandemic halted transfers, and denied political pressure, Detik reported.
- On 4 August 2025, Attorney General's Office (Kejagung) spokesman Anang Supriatna said Silfester "must be executed" because the verdict was final, Kompas reported.
- Prosecutorial Commission member Nurokhman said in August 2025 that execution did not need to wait for Silfester's case review petition, which a court later dropped because he never attended, Kompas reported. In October 2025 Kejagung said it had not found him and asked his lawyers to cooperate, Kompas TV reported. It has not put him on the wanted list.
- On 31 December 2025 Kejagung said it was still searching and had brought in its fugitive tracking team, Kompas reported.
- On 25 September 2026 Anang said execution was "fully the authority" of the South Jakarta prosecutors and "we will coordinate again", Sindonews reported.
Where he has been seen
- 4 August 2025: Silfester spoke to reporters at Jakarta police headquarters after questioning as a witness in another case, saying "no problem" if he were jailed, Kompas reported.
- 2025: He was appointed independent commissioner of state food holding ID Food, Tirto reported. Kompas noted in August 2025 that he still appeared on television.
- 18 September 2026: Pelindo Jasa Maritim, a state port services firm, appointed him independent commissioner by shareholder decision, then removed him on 23 September after an evaluation, Tirto reported.
- 15 November 2026: A video circulating online of a restaurant opening attended by Deputy Manpower Minister Afriansyah Noor shows a man said to be Silfester. BaliNews said the identity was not confirmed. NewsWLD could not verify it.
His lawyer Lechumanan said in October 2025 that Silfester was in Jakarta and had not fled. In January 2026 NasDem legislator Machfud Arifin told the Attorney General in a DPR hearing: "Who is Silfester? Not brave enough?" Kompas reported. Intelligence analyst Sri Radjasa Chandra called the case the most visible failure of Attorney General ST Burhanuddin's tenure on 14 November 2026, Monitor Indonesia and Law-Justice reported.
The case is not about corruption, but it shows the gap between a final verdict and its enforcement when the convict is politically connected. Prosecutors say they cannot find a man who was named to two state company boards while they were looking for him.
Nusron: a witness who delayed, then appeared
Land Minister Nusron Wahid is not a suspect. The KPK summoned him as a witness in a bribery case over unblocking building rights (HGB) for Summarecon land in Bogor, in which it named eight suspects after a sting in September 2026, including a director general at his ministry. The KPK said four of the suspects were people Nusron trusted, Monitor Indonesia reported.
He did not appear on 7 October 2026, citing an internal ministry agenda, or on 15 October, citing an official trip that KPK said was likely to Malaysia, Kompas reported. On 21 October he attended a plenary cabinet session at the palace, seen in the presidential secretariat's broadcast, Kompas and CNN Indonesia reported. On 4 November he came to the KPK and was questioned for about five hours, Detik reported.
So the "seen at meetings while dodging" image fits Nusron for those two weeks in October, but the KPK did not say it could not find him, and he was eventually questioned. The Kompas English edition's editorial of 20 October grouped him with Silfester as a test of how law enforcement treats people close to power.
Read our full analysis: Back in parliament, out early, unexecuted: the gaps in Indonesia's punishment of the powerful.
Sources
- 1.Detik: Eks Kajari Jaksel ungkap alasan Silfester tak dieksekusi, news.detik.com
- 2.Kompas: Silfester siap ditahan, di Polda Metro Jaya, megapolitan.kompas.com
- 3.Kompas: Benarkah Silfester sulit dieksekusi karena punya ipar di Kejari, kompas.com
- 4.Tempo: Keberadaan Silfester Matutina masih jadi misteri, tempo.co
- 5.Metro TV: Kejagung lempar bola ke Kejari Jaksel soal status buron Silfester, metrotvnews.com
- 6.Kompas TV: Kejagung akui belum temukan keberadaan Silfester, kompas.tv
- 7.Kompas: Anggota DPR kritik Kejagung belum tangkap Silfester, nasional.kompas.com
- 8.Tirto: Silfester 5 hari jadi komisaris Pelindo JM, tirto.id
- 9.Sindonews: Kejagung buka suara soal eksekusi Silfester, nasional.sindonews.com
- 10.BaliNews: Wamenaker di pembukaan resto, video tampilkan sosok diduga Silfester, balinews.id
- 11.Monitor Indonesia: Desakan copot Jaksa Agung kembali menguat, monitorindonesia.com
- 12.Law-Justice: Desakan copot JA menguat, kasus Silfester dan Febrie, law-justice.co
- 13.Monitor Indonesia: KPK buru lingkaran Nusron, monitorindonesia.com
- 14.Kompas: Nusron hadiri rapat kabinet usai 2 kali tak penuhi panggilan KPK, nasional.kompas.com
- 15.CNN Indonesia: Mangkir dari panggilan KPK, Nusron hadiri sidang kabinet, cnnindonesia.com
- 16.Detik: Menteri Nusron Wahid penuhi panggilan KPK, news.detik.com
- 17.Kompas (English): The KPK must be firm on legal ghosts, go.kompas.com




