What was said
An election audit uncovered 228,000 fraudulent votes for Zohran Mamdani in the 2025 New York City mayoral election, enough to overturn his victory.
Claimed by X account @merican_great, 19 November 2026, citing Rudy Giuliani and a RealAmerica.Vote report · social media
Our verdict
The assertion that an audit uncovered 228,000 fraudulent votes for Mamdani is false. The cited RealAmerica.Vote study was not an official election audit: it extrapolated 228,389 supposed eligibility concerns from a sample of 10,000 voter records, without verifying fraudulent ballots or whom those voters supported. Some flags relied on Social Security number assumptions inconsistent with the SSA's post-2011 randomization rules; gaps in a commercial database are not proof of ineligibility. This does not establish that every registration was valid, but it provides no evidence of 228,000 fraudulent votes for Mamdani or an overturned certified result.
The facts
- 1
The NYC Board of Elections publishes certified returns for the November 4, 2025 mayoral election; the cited social-media allegation is not an official election audit.
NYC Board of Elections: Election Results Summary 2025 - 2
RealAmerica.Vote extrapolated 228,389 suspected eligibility issues from 10,000 sampled voter records; its report did not verify fraudulent ballots or candidate choices.
Lead Stories: Fact Check: NO Evidence 'Audit' Found 228,000 Fraudulent Votes For Mamdani - 3
The Social Security Administration implemented randomized SSN assignment on June 25, 2011, invalidating assumptions that all numbers beginning with 773 or higher are fraudulent.
Social Security Administration: Social Security Number Randomization - 4
Certified 2025 mayoral results gave Mamdani 1,114,184 votes and Cuomo 906,614, a margin of 207,570 votes; that margin alone does not validate the alleged 228,000 fraudulent votes.
NPR: New York election results: certified mayoral totals
Published fact checks
- Independent review of RealAmerica.Vote report and original viral post · Lead Stories
- Official 2025 election results · NYC Board of Elections
People and issues
Checked 22 November 2026. A claim is quoted as it circulated; the verdict comes from the facts listed here, each linked to its source. If you spot an error or have a newer record, tell us through the contact page and we will correct it openly.
← All fact checks